Financial Services Bank on Growth in an Era of Uncertainty
by CC Williams
Size matters a lot in the world of financial services. Like dinosaurs,
financial behemoths rule each sector of the competitive, lucrative financial
services industry - CitiGroup Inc. in banking, PricewaterhouseCoopers LLC
in accounting and consulting and Prudential Insurance of America in insurance.
Spurred by competition and technology, financial firms think the way to
customers' pocketbooks is to offer more services and products than the
other guy. For the most part, it's working, with sectors such as banking
and
securities pumping out a bevy of products and generating impressive
revenue
and profits. ''The financial service sector has been very successful
in recent years and it's expected to continue,'' says Lee Price, chief
economist at the U.S. Department of Commerce.
Financial services, which Price describes as ''the instrument for allocating
savings and investments in the country,'' is a growing slice of the overall
economic pie. Finance, insurance and real estate represented 19.4%
of gross domestic product (GDP) in 1997, or $1.57 trillion, up from 18.9%
in 1996, according to the Bureau of Economic Analysis. Financial services
is expected to be a boom industry of the next decade due, in part, to the
accumulation of private wealth. However, things aren't all rosy. The mature
insurance sector is suffering from sluggish growth and declining operating
profits as fewer people buy life insurance. The securities and investment
business can be volatile, as last year's collapse of global capital markets
and bankruptcy of hedge fund Long-term Capital Management show. In addition,
a slowdown in the economy and a rise in interest rates could slow growth
of the rocketing stock market and hurt companies' profits.
The sector is undergoing major fundamental changes that promise to increase
competition as well as opportunities. Consolidation continues to transform
the face of many businesses, especially banking and insurance. Geographical
borders continue to blur as more foreign institutions buy American firms
and vice versa. Many firms are also bracing for the passage of the financial
services reform bill, which would tear down the legal barriers limiting
securities firms, banks and insurance companies from entering one another's
markets, thus repealing the Glass-Steagall Act. Both Houses of Congress
passed different versions earlier this year. President Clinton could decide
on a compromise bill this year. While it would accelerate the
creation of financial superstores, the bill would also intensify competition
among firms and lead to fewer financial companies.
The sector, heavily dependent on computer systems, is also
eyeing the
arrival of the new millennium with some trepidation. Many firms have
taken
billions of dollars in reserve to get their systems ready for year
2000, but
there are sure to be some problems. The consulting firms, however,
like
PricewaterhouseCoopers and Ernst & Young, are getting additional
revenue
from Y2K- related work by helping companies prepare for the new era.
And, of
course, there's the Internet, likely the most significant force sweeping
through the industry and the whole economy. The commoditizing of services
that the web brings will lead to more intense competition and lower
profits
for many companies. But many smart firms are learning how to exploit
the
exploding technology, ensuring their place in the Web era.
The industry is also under pressure to include more minorities. While
their numbers remain disturbingly low, African Americans represent 10.5
percent of the finance, insurance and real estate sectors as of 1998, according
to the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS). The African-American presence
is being felt in almost every corner of the business and occasionally at
the top. In April, the American Express Company announced President Kenneth
I. Chenault would become chief executive officer for the giant New York-based
financial-services and travel firm in 2001. Financial firms, hungry to
tap the burgeoning minority market, are beefing up their diversity programs
and recruitment of minority graduates.
Along with American Express, California-based Charles Schwab is leading
the charge to pitch its products to minorities and increase minorities
on its employee rolls. ''You can't market to minority groups unless you
are reflective of that population,'' says Michael DeFlorimonte (left), who, as
vice president of specialized markets, is responsible for Schwab's minority
marketing efforts, which include aligning with minority firms such as Ariel
Capital Management. Schwab held an investment education workshop at Morehouse
College in the Spring and is planning another at Florida A&M University
in the Fall, according to DeFlorimonte. The firm uses these events as recruiting
tools, he says.
Some sectors should show growth in employment. The industry needs investment
bankers to find capital for the increasing flow of companies looking
to expand or go public, accountants to understand the increasingly complicated
merger deals and financial sales reps to sell and understand the flood
of financial products hitting the markets. But, overall, as Lee Price
notes, the financial services sector ''won't grow rapidly on the employment
side due to technology'' but the jobs created will be good jobs and well
paying. For almost eight years, Michelle Owens has occupied one of those
jobs. She earns a ''six-figure'' salary as a financial consultant at one
of the giants in the industry, Salomon Smith Barney. ''My job offers
total freedom,'' says the Harvard MBA. ''I'm making a difference in folks'
lives and there's potential for unlimited income.''
Few sectors are as affected by consolidation and technology as the banking
industry, which has gone from tellers to ATM to Internet banking in almost
no time at all. To compete in the new world, banks are buying each other
to spread technological and other costs across a broader and broader customer
base. In the most dramatic example: NationsBank and Bank America merged
in 1998, creating a behemoth with more than $600 billion in assets and
tentacles in 36 countries. Everyone, it seems, wants to be like Citigroup,
which was formed in 1998 from the $73 billion merger of Citicorp and the
Travelers Group Inc. It's seen as the prototypical financial supermarket,
offering brokerage, asset management and insurance to people all over the
globe. The banking reform bill should make the creation of financial superstores
easier. However, it would also allow securities firms to buy banks
for the first time.
Banks can buy securities firms under current rules.
Consolidation is shrinking the number of banks in the U.S. It's also
creating an industry with very large banks at the top and small ones at
the bottom and fewer mid-sized banks. But analysts expect the next
wave of mergers to be led by small community banks, with assets of $1 billion
or less, buying each other in a rush to increase their size. The sector
is relatively healthy. The amount of money banks hold is increasing and
profits are rising. According to the Federal Deposit Insurance Corp., 8,721
commercial banks - a decline from 8,774 from the beginning of the quarter
--
reported a record $18 billion net income in the first quarter of 1999,
12.9 percent higher than the year-ago previous quarter on total assets
of $34.1 billion. The 1,669 savings institutions reported $2.7 billion
in net income for the quarter, the group's third-highest in history.
But mergers and technological changes are also crimping employment. According
to the BLS, banks employed more than two million wage and salaried workers,
making it the largest of the finance, insurance and real estates sectors
in terms of manpower. But the bureau sees employment in banking slipping
4 percent
over the 1996-2006 period. Loan officers and financial service sales
representatives
are expected to see gains among their ranks, however.
Bureau records show that 12.6 percent of those employed in the
banking sector in
1998 are African Americans, a relatively decent percentage. The perception
is that banks are more aggressive in hiring minorities than other sectors
of the financial services industry such as insurance. New York-based Chase
Manhattan, the third largest bank in the U.S. with $291 billion in assets,
is cited as having an especially strong diversity program, forming 35 diversity
councils in the past two years. Much of that is probably driven by the
industry's closer adherence to the Community Reinvestment Act of 1997,
mandating that regulators consider a bank's record in meeting credit needs
in minority and under-served areas when considering merger applications.
Another healthy sector is the securities and investment services business.
Fueled by the historic bull market and influx of money into the U.S. equity
markets from baby boomers and foreign investors, the leading Wall Street
firms such as Merrill Lynch, and the Goldman Sachs Group have generated
increasing revenue from underwriting IPOs, advising on mergers and acquisitions
and trading securities. From 1980 to 1997, securities firm capital grew
13-fold to $92 billion and security industry revenue increased nine-fold
to $145 billion, according to the Securities Industry Association.
The New York rating service Standard & Poor's expects the investment
services
industry to report pre-tax profits of between $12 billion and $13 billion
in 1999, up sharply from 1998's $9.8 billion, when the global crisis
in capital markets hurt business.
The virtual explosion of online trading is helping to push growth of
the securities business. Through leading firms such as Charles Schwab
and E-Trade Group, investors can trade stocks conveniently through the
web-based accounts for as low as one-tenth the commission of traditional
firms. Industry consultants Forrester Research in Cambridge, Mass, expects
the number of online accounts to grow to 18 million by the year 2001 from
1.5 million in 1996. After much hesitation, traditional firms are finally
endorsing online trading, which was stealing away customers. In early June,
Merrill Lynch said it would offer customers online trades for $29.95,
matching Charles Schwab.
Strong business should spur employment. According to the BLS, employment
among securities, commodity and investment companies should increase 34
percent
between 1996 and 2006, outpacing the 14 percent expected for all industries
combined. The sector had 551,000 wage and salaried workers in 1996.
The hot job areas will be corporate finance, retail and institutional asset
management, notes Bernard B. Beal, chief executive of M.R. Beal & Co.,
an African-American investment banking and financial advisory firm in New
York. Beal's also co-chairman of the SIA's diversity committee.
With all that money flowing into securities' business, there's more
pressure on the sector to share more of it with minorities. If banks are
being complimented for creating more diversity, Wall Street securities
and brokerage firms are still being criticized for clinging to its image
as a bastion of white males. The sector has seen its share of high-profile
wrongful discrimination cases, including the $1.35 billion suit brought
by an
African- American securities analyst, Christian L. Curry, of Morgan
Stanley Dean Witter & Co. A recent study by the SIA found that women
and minorities hold a greater share of management jobs in lower paying
sectors of the business, such as administration compared with real money
making operations, like investment banking and retail sales. Across Wall
Street, the SIA survey, based on employees of the responding firms, showed
that minorities make up 11.5 percent of the workforce and African
Americans 4.5 percent.
The insurance business represents about 8% of
GDP, according to Robert
P. Hartwig (right), vice president and chief economist at the Insurance Information
Institute, an industry trade group in New York. The industry, divided in
two broad categories, life and health and property-casualty insurance,
provided 2.3 million jobs at the end of 1997 and controlled assets
of $3.4 trillion, according to the Insurance Institute. There are
7,900 domestic insurance companies in the U.S. According to the BLS,
employment in health and pension funds insurance industries is expected
to grow rapidly over the next seven years while life insurance employment
may see a decline. Overall, the BLS sees wage and salary jobs in the insurance
industry growing 11 percent from 1996 through 2006. Business, however,
is far from healthy. Standard & Poor's pointed out that statutory earnings
for life insurers dropped 18 percent in 1998 from a year ago and the fundamentals
of the property-casualty sector, where premium has been declining,
remain weak. The sector paid out a lot of money last year to cover a near
record $10.1 billion worth of catastrophes. This year is also running high,
says Hartwig.
Like the other sectors, the sleepy insurance business is facing rapid
changes brought by intense consolidation. Since 1994, merger and acquisition
activity in the sector has been vigorous. The industry saw 565 mergers
and acquisitions (M&A) in 1998, representing $165.4 billion, according
to Hartwig, who sees M&A activity slowing
a bit this year. Much of that involved foreign companies buying U.S.
firms. But U.S.
companies are also looking overseas, especially Latin America, he says.
The sector is
seeing more financial institutions, such as banks, sell insurance.
To compete, some
insurance companies are divesting their non-core operations and focusing
on providing
simpler insurance products. More companies are also deciding to go
fully public, or demutualize, which should give them more money for acquisitions and
expansion.
Furthermore, more and more Americans are buying insurance over the Internet,
cutting out the sales agents and threatening a vital part of the traditional
insurance system. Like brokerage firms, traditional firms face a dilemma:
How do they also sell insurance over the net without eliminating their
own sales force? Helping to come up with the answer for State Farm Insurance
Co. is part of Harold Gray's (right) responsibility as a regional vice president.
Gray, who oversees 2,100 employees, says State Farm, which has more than
75,000 employees and around 16,000 agents, is ''working feverishly'' to
determine how to exploit the web without displacing its agents. The
company's site,
listed as one of the top ten insurance sites according to some industry
observers, offers quotes to customers on policies.
It's indeed a good time for African-American graduates to consider the
financial services industry. In this era of enormous uncertainty, targeting
minorities, either as employees or customers, is one of the soundest business
decisions companies can make. However, while demand is expected to be strong
for qualified graduates, employers' standards remain high. So graduates
need to be even more prepared. A sharp financial acumen, honed by accounting
and statistics courses, is the key to landing a top job. But many employers
are still emphasizing soft ''people'' skills as well.
Just ask Whitney
Baker (left). In her travel-heavy job as a senior business
development officer at Sovereign Bank in New Jersey, Baker puts her strong
networking and people skills to work to meet her monthly quota of $3 million
in loans. ''Even if you work in the back office doing underwriting,
you must be able to work with clients,'' the New Jersey native says. ''If
you aren't a people- person, you probably don't want to enter this arena.''
Graduates must also be flexible, knowing that, with companies sometimes
changing hands overnight, where they start in a career might not be where
they end up.
Chart Listing of Several Top Firms in Key Financial Service
(Source: a 1999 Fortune magazine list unless otherwise indicated.)
BANKS
1. Citigroup: $76,431.00 (revenues in millions) 170,100
(employees)
2. Bank of America: $50,777.00 - 170,975
3. Chase Manhattan: $32,379.00 - 72,683
SECURITIES FIRMS
1. Merrill Lynch & Co.: $35,853.00 (revenues in millions) 63,800
(employees)
2. Morgan Stanley Dean Witter: $31,131.00 - 49,300
3. Lehman Brothers: $19,894.00 - 8,873
INSURANCE
1. State Farm Insurance Cos.:$44,620.90 (revenues in millions) 76,257
(employees)
2. TIAA-CREF: $35,889.13 - 5,229
3. Prudential Insurance Co.: $34,427.00 of America - 77,806
Real Estate Brokerages/Services (Residential)
(Provided by Real Trends, Inc., a real estate publication and communications
firm) Size is measured by closed sales volume.
1. NRT Inc. $84 billion (closed sales volume) - 30,000 agents and 4,800
staff
2. Yeichert' Realtors: $16 billion - 7,200 agents and 1,000 staff
3. Long & Foster, Real Estate, Inc.: $10.5 billion - 5,650 agents
and 968 staff
Commercial Real Estate
(1998 figures provided by Market Guide)
1. CB Richard & Ellis Services Inc.: $1,034.5 billion (sales)
- 9,400 (employees)
2. Trammell Crow Co.: $517.5 million - 5,100 employees
3. Grubb & Ellis Co.: $282.8 million - 4,400 employees
CC Williams is a New York City-based financial services' writer
specializing in personal finance and minority business issues.
|