A
Murder In Virginia
Southern Justice On Trial
by Suzanne Lebsock
In 1895, memories of
slavery and the Civil War were still fresh, and the tensions between blacks and
whites percolated just below the surface in the South. When Lucy Jane Pollard
was murdered with an ax in her home in rural Lunenburg County, Virginia, that
summer, it brought these simmering issues to a boil. Pollard was fifty-six years
old, white, and married to a prosperous farmer, and her murder was accompanied
by the disappearance of a large sum of money from their farmhouse. A black
millhand was apprehended after he was seen spending a stack of suspicious
twenty-dollar bills, and in a false confession under pressure he pinned the
murder on a trio of black women in Lunenburg.
What followed was a murder trial that
dominated newspaper headlines for the next year and a half. In A MURDER
IN VIRGINIA: Southern Justice on Trial, University of Washington history
professor and Bancroft Prize-winning author Suzanne Lebsock relates
the gripping details of the courtroom drama while placing the case in historical
context. Lucy Jane Pollard's murder was truly a landmark case one that showcased
the growing racial divide in the South following Reconstruction, the rise of
White Supremacy in the South, and a discord between rural and urban politics.
Lunenburg, Virginia, was after all decidedly off the beaten path situated
between Richmond and the North Carolina border, and the local farmers heavily
resented the involvement of state lawmakers and distant newspapermen in their
affairs.
However,
Lebsock wisely points out how much about the Pollard murder case defied
predictions. A MURDER IN VIRGINIA highlights how the murder of a
middle-aged farmer's wife generated interest way beyond the little town of
Lunenburg. In Richmond, a national grassroots movement was started by the black
community to aid the defendants. Lebsock also details how the poor, uneducated
women proved to be quite adept at cross-examination in the courtroom. In
addition, she relates how some of the white farmers from Lunenburg actually went
out of their way to prevent the unlawful lynchings of their black neighbors.
Even though Lucy Jane Pollard's murder
dominated headlines and underscored many of the racial, class, and
urban-versus-rural issues facing the post-Reconstruction South, history has
largely left it by the wayside. The other big news story of the day-the one with
which the murder vied for newspaper attention-was the fantastic rise and
crashing fall of Populism. While history books continue to pay great attention
to Populism and the presidential race of 1896, Pollard's murder trial-which was,
in its day, as racially galvanizing as the O.J. Simpson or Rodney King
cases-has been ignored. Now, Lebsock has written the first and only incisive,
detailed report of what took place and how it became a sign of the times.
A MURDER IN VIRGINIA is
both a thrilling courtroom drama and a wise historical narrative illuminating
the South in the throes of change. It also shows how the legacy of that time-for
good and ill-lives on.
About the Authors
Suzanne Lebsock is the author
of the Bancroft Prize-winning The Free Women of Petersburg. A Murder In
Virginia won the Francis Parkman Prize and was a finalist for the American
Bar Association's Silver Gavel Award. The recipient of a MacArthur fellowship,
Lebsock is Board of Governors Professor of History at Rutgers University in New Jersey.
A Murder In Virginia:
Southern Justice On Trial
By Suzanne Lebsock
Price: $15.95
ISBN: 0-393-32606-3
|