Prosperity Bodes Well for the Hospitality Industry in the New Millennium
by Dr. Steven e. Campbell
The multi-billion dollar plus a year hospitality industry
includes lodging, food service, institutional facilities and travel and
recreation. Food service was its largest and most profitable segment in 1999
while time share and theme park sectors also fared well. The food and beverage
segment is divided into three areas: chains, corporate, and independents.
According to Nation's Restaurant News, a leading industry trade
publication, the top food and beverage chains/corporations were as follows:
|
1999
Ranking |
1998
Ranking |
Chain |
Concept |
U.S. System-wide Food -service Sales
(By Fiscal Year, In Millions) |
|
1 |
1 |
McDonald’s |
Sandwich |
$18,123.0 |
|
2 |
2 |
Burger King |
Sandwich |
8,245.0 |
|
3 |
4 |
Taco Bell |
Sandwich |
5,000.0 |
|
4 |
5 |
Wendy’s |
Sandwich |
4,994.2 |
|
5 |
3 |
Pizza Hut |
Pizza |
4,800.0 |
|
6 |
6 |
KFC |
Chicken |
4,200.0 |
|
7 |
7 |
Armark Global Food/Leisure Services |
Contract |
3,437.0 |
|
8 |
8 |
Subway |
Sandwich |
3,100.0 |
|
9 |
9 |
Hardee’s |
Sandwich |
2,394.0 |
|
10 |
10 |
Domino’s Pizza |
Pizza |
2,300.0 |
|
11 |
12 |
Arby’s |
Sandwich |
2,077.0 |
|
12 |
15 |
Applebee’s Neighborhood Grill & Bar |
Dinner House |
2,032.0 |
|
13 |
11 |
Dairy Queen |
Sandwich |
2,015.0 |
|
14 |
13 |
Denny’s |
Family |
1,963.0 |
|
15 |
16 |
Dunkin’ Donuts |
Snack |
1,960.0 |
|
16 |
14 |
Red Lobster |
Dinner House |
1,932.0 |
|
17 |
18 |
Olive Garden |
Dinner House |
1,490.0 |
|
18 |
19 |
Jack in the Box |
Sandwich |
1,452.9 |
|
19 |
22 |
Outback Steakhouse |
Dinner House |
1,447.0 |
|
20 |
20 |
Marriott hotels, resorts & suites |
Hotel |
1,390.0 |
|
21 |
21 |
Chili’s Grill & Bar |
Dinner House |
1,375.0 |
|
22 |
25 |
Sonic Drive-In |
Sandwich |
1,337.9 |
|
23 |
17 |
Little Caesar’s Pizza |
Pizza |
1,250.0 |
|
24 |
28 |
LSG Lufthansa Service Sky Chef |
Contract |
1,220.0 |
|
25 |
34 |
Papa John’s Pizza |
Pizza |
1,156.3 |
Sales of sandwiches represented 42.15% of the estimated $370.72 billion in
revenue generated in 1999 by the food service industry. Besides sandwich sales,
the food service marketing mix leading into January 2000 was:
Sandwich 42.15%
Contract Feeding 11.53%
Dinner House 9.83%
Pizza 8.84%
Family Restaurant 7.22%
Chicken 5.95%
Hotel 4.41%
Coffee shops, Theme Park Buffet 3.69%
Snack Bars 2.33%
Grill Buffet 2.18%
Fish 1.00%
Convenience store .87%
* Source: National Restaurant Association
The nation's most profitable independent restaurants as noted by Restaurants
and Institutions are:
| |
Restaurant |
City |
'98 Sales-($MM) |
|
1 |
Tavern on the Green |
New York |
34,200 |
|
2 |
Windows on the World |
New York |
31,870 |
|
3 |
Smith & Wollensky |
New York |
24,446 |
|
4 |
Bob Chinn’s Crab House |
Wheeling, Ill |
21,708 |
|
5 |
Sparks Steakhouse |
New York |
20,400 |
|
6 |
Joe’s Stone Crab |
Miami Beach, FL. |
19,035 |
|
7 |
‘21’ Club |
New York |
17,289 |
|
8 |
Fulton’s Crab House |
Lake Buena Vista, FL. |
16,000 |
|
9 |
Four Seasons |
New York |
15,083 |
|
10 |
The Lobster House |
Cape May, NJ |
14,954 |
It should be noted that Tavern on the Green, the nation's most profitable
independent restaurant, was under the direct supervision for several years by
the late Patrick Clark, the restaurant's first African-American executive chef,
who died in February of 1998.
Current Trends in the Food Service Industry
The Industry has numerous eating establishments opening yearly, each
entrepreneur seeking to convince the public or target market that his/her new
concept is unique. Despite high business failure rates, some new concepts look
like winners and "catch on as what's in." This is mainly due to
creativity, sound marketing, feasibility studies, and luck. This author has had
the opportunity to dine at a few of the "hot concepts" winners as
cited by Nation's Restaurant News and agrees they are unique.
|
RESTAURANT NAME
|
TYPE OF CONCEPT |
LOCATION |
|
Bahama Breeze |
Caribbean-theme casual dining |
Orlando, FL |
|
Kahunaville |
Theme/Casual |
Wilmington, Del. |
|
King’s Fish House |
Upper-end casual dinner house with emphasis on fresh seafood |
Long Beach, Calif. |
|
Razzoo’s Cajun Café |
Casual Gulf Coast seafood |
Irving, TX |
|
Rodizio Grill |
Brazilian churrascaria |
Denver |
|
Roly Poly |
Rolled sandwiches |
Jacksonville, FL |
As noted in the hospitality industry report for this magazine last year,
theme restaurants by and large are "dead" and "high
risk" for investors. Planet Hollywood filed for bankruptcy in August 1999
and the Fashion Café closed its doors in January, 1999, as did The Motown
Café, also located in midtown Manhattan, in May, 1999. Some of the problems
contributing to the lack of profitability of theme restaurants are:
- Exorbitant rents (rumored to exceed $75,000 a month for the Motown Café).
- Union scale wages to the entertainers/staff.
- Employee theft.
- Stagnant menu. A cycle menu is necessary in theme restaurants to keep the
public's interest.
- Inflated prices.
- Most customers are one-time visitors; lack of repeat customers.
In 1997, the Motown Café opened a restaurant in Las Vegas that is still
afloat and more recently opened a facility in Orlando, Florida, at Universal
Studios' Island of Adventure. Plans for a Tokyo restaurant are in the making.
The Tokyo Motown Café should be successful due to the large following of the
Motown aura and mystique among the Japanese. Theme restaurants are basically
built on today's crazes. "Wrestle mania" is "in," so a
wrestling- theme restaurant is scheduled to open in Manhattan. It is hard to
conceive that a chain of these restaurants nationwide will be around in 2005. To
reiterate, do not invest in theme restaurants unless you are financially sound
and have the patience to wait a substantial period of time for a return on your
initial investment.
International
Due to the economic problems in Asia, as well as political unrest in Eastern
Europe, India and Pakistan, caution is the key word for many chain restaurants
as they seek to expand globally.
Asia once viewed as the most dynamic market for industry expansion, saw its
once powerful economy collapse several years ago. Since the 1997 depression,
European and American chains have either postponed or sharply curtailed their
expansion in the Pacific Rim. However, there are some analysts who assert Asia
is recovering, and it would be fiscally wise to take advantage of the depressed
real estate markets. Prior to the depression, Asian real estate costs often
would consume 15-20% of a restaurant's gross income. Comparatively, in key
American markets, such as San Francisco, New York City and Boston rents usually
do not exceed 4% or 5% of gross revenue. The second rationale analysts are
suggesting is that companies may wish to re-invest in Asia, particularly Japan,
in that the average Japanese citizen spends nearly $1,500 per year "dining
out" or about $700 more than the average American. The third factor for
reinvestment in Asia is the currency exchange rates have become stable and that
the worst of the regions fiscal problems have been settled.
Canada, Latin America and the Caribbean have replaced Asia as the "Hot
Markets" for expansion. Chains such as Wendy’s International and Outback
Steakhouse plan to expand in the areas cited above. Latin America will account
for about 50% of the international chains Wendy’s will likely open this
decade. Outback is projecting to double its half dozen existing stores in the
Latin America and Caribbean area within 18-24 months. Tricon Global Restaurants,
Inc., the parent company of Pizza Hut, KFC and Taco Bell, plans to open 800 new
international stores by the years end. Subway Restaurant currently has 750
stores in 70 foreign nations including four in China and projects 1,000 foreign
units to be open by early 2001. The premier giant of the chain restaurant
industry, McDonald's, anticipates opening 15 restaurants in the Ukraine and
expects to have 85 restaurants in the area by 2005. Overall, the industry is
slowing its expansion internationally and focusing on positive markets which
possess economic and political stability.
The Black Culinarian Alliance (BCA), founded in 1993, "is a
national, non-profit, educational and networking organization devoted to the
enhancement of professional opportunities for minorities within the hospitality
industry," according to board members Chef Alex Askew, co-founder of the
organization, and Rochelle Brown, producer of "Emeril Live." They
further asserted, "The BCA’s mission is to increase awareness, exposure
and education of minorities by sponsoring hospitality scholarships, seminars,
culinary training and creating media events." The organization is equally
committed to establishing a strategic alliance with the Latino community and
with Latino hospitality professionals."
The lodging industry expects continued growth in this century. Pursuant to
PricewaterhouseCoopers' statistics, the 1999 lodging industry profits were
estimated to rise 14%. The firm noted that this increase marks the sixth
consecutive year of profitability wherein the trends expect to continue until
next year.
|
RECORD PROFITABILITY
Following is the actual and forecasted aggregate hotel industry
profits: |
|
1997 |
|
$17.3 billion |
|
1998 |
|
$18.9 billion |
|
1999 |
|
$20.1 billion |
|
2000 |
|
$21.2 billion |
|
2001 |
|
$22.3 billion |
|
Source: PricewaterhouseCoopers |
Industry leaders assert revenue derived from business travel will remain
docile; however, due to the strong economy at the close of the last century, the
new millennium will see leisure travel revenue continue to be strong. Travel
industry analysts predicted a 4% increase in 1999. There was an increase in
travel to the United States and a decrease in travel to Europe, partially due to
the instability in Central Europe, particularly Kosovo. It should be noted that
the overall occupancy rate was projected to fall from 63.9 in 1998 to 63.5 in
1999. However, the average room rates projected to increase from $78.62 in 1998
to $81.61 in 1999, actually had risen to $84.87, according to Smith Travel
research consultants.
Timeshares
Once known as "quick, get rich" pyramid schemes/scams for
unsuspecting travelers and investors, government regulators and industry
officials have "professionalized and polished" the once-tarnished name
of timeshares. The timeshare market reached record sales in1999. The American
Resort Development Association, which monitors the timeshare industry, noted
that annual worldwide timeshare revenue exceeded six billion dollars. Timeshare
development projects have grown 24% worldwide since 1994. United States
timeshare sales have increased 72% during the same time period.
Theme Parks
Theme parks are not opened for fun; they are opened for profits--big
profits. Attendance in 1998 at America's 50 most successful theme parks was over
165 million people, with estimated revenues of 8 billion dollars just on
admission tickets, not including food, merchandise, etc. If attendance from
smaller parks is included, the number exceeds 270 million people or the entire
population of the United States. It is predicted theme park attendance will
increase 10% by 2010. There was a small decline in attendance in 1998 due to the
forces of nature--El Nino in California and the major brush fires in Florida
adjacent to I-95, the major highway to the Disney World Resort, coupled with the
economic problems in Asia and Canada which curtailed international visitation.
As noted above, theme parks grossed an estimated 8 billion dollars in admission
fees. The average admission fee is about $34 per person and at major parks such
as Walt Disney World, the price exceeded $45. The $50 one-day admission ticket
is in the not too distant future. In addition, patrons will consume an average
of three meals a day at these parks. Revenue from food and beverage sales for
each guest averages $20.
Employment Opportunities -- Salaries and Diversity
Three years ago, the NAACP issued the controversial "report card"
on the lodging/hospitality industry's failure to hire and promote women and
minorities. This is coupled with the fact that several lawsuits were filed
against large chains such as Cracker Barrel, Denny's, Shoney's, Motel 6 and
Pizza Hut for employment and accommodation discrimination. Ernestine Green,
chairperson of the Statler Foundation, notes: "As the industry enters the
new millennium, many of the employment barriers that were once prevalent during
the last century, no longer exist. However, it is up to the next generation of
hospitality workers to enjoin the possible resurgence of those barriers. This
can be achieved if the prospective minority and non-minority employee adhere to
the following tasks:"
1. Be dedicated to the profession.
2. Adhere to training procedures.
3. Establish positive work objectives.
4. Maintain a positive attitude toward one’s job.
5. Develop and reinforce the skills necessary to maintain suitable employment
for all employees.
6. And most important, be a "people person."
In light of the above and the strong economy, corporations have actively
recruited women and minorities for decision-making positions within their
corporate structure
Culinary Arts Workforce and Diversity
Projections for 1994 – 2005
1994
Caucasian 71. %
Hispanic American 13.1%
African American
11.4%
29% minorities
Asian American 4.5%
2000
Caucasian 68.5%
Hispanic American 14.4%
African American
11.6%
31.5% minorities
Asian American 5.5%
2005
Caucasian 66.5%
Hispanic American 15.5%
African American
11.7%
33.5% minorities
Asian American 6.3%
The National Restaurant Association projected that in the 10-year period
covering 1996-2006, the demand for management employees would increase by 35% or
an additional 515,000 management-level personnel. In order to fill the need,
major corporations are actively recruiting at Historically Black Colleges and
Universities which have hospitality-related degree programs. According to
Professor Gloria Tate, former coordinator of Hospitality at Morris Brown College
in Atlanta, Georgia, "The recent surge in the economy has meant numerous
employment opportunities for African Americans, both male and female, in the
hospitality industry."
Associate Dean Donald Bishop at Cornell University's, School of Hotel
Administration, Ithaca, New York, considered to be the world's premier academic
institution for hospitality, asserts the previous year’s class received an
"average of three job offers." Half of the student body accepted
positions in hotels and resorts, the other half accepted positions with food
service firms." One third of the class accepted employment in the areas of
consulting, finance, and investment banking with brokerage firms that had
hospitality divisions.
The average undergraduate starting salary for the 1999 Cornell hospitality
graduates was $34,500 with a $2,500 signing bonus or a $37,000 package. One
Cornell undergraduate demanded and received a $70,000 starting salary plus a
signing bonus! Starting salaries nationwide for males and females were equal.
Dean Bishop notes a number of major corporations, such as Marriott and Hyatt,
are actively recruiting "protected class/minority" graduates to
eventually move into corporate management. He emphasizes the prospective
graduate who has aspirations of upper management should have a strong background
in finance, real estate, and accounting.
As noted, the late 1990s finally saw female and male graduates receiving
equal starting salaries. However, this was not always the case. "Female
executives’ salaries," a phrase almost unheard of prior to 1980, still
lagged behind male executives’ salaries. According to Working Woman, females
armed with a college degree earned approximately $4,708 a year more than men who
only possessed a high school diploma.
|
"Working Woman’s" 1998 Salary Survey
provided the following annual median salary information for women in
hospitality/hotels: |
| |
|
|
POSITION |
SALARY |
|
C.F.O. |
$97,000 |
|
V.P. Sales & Marketing |
$76,000 |
|
V.P. Operations |
$73,000 |
|
Regional Manager |
$65,000 |
|
Dir. Of Development |
$61,000 |
|
Corporate Controller |
$55,000 |
|
General Manager |
$54,000 |
|
Source: "Working Woman" |
Betsy Brown, president of Hospitality International, in a recent interview
for Hotel and Motel Management, noted a number of female employees were
finally receiving recognition for their contributions to the lodging industry.
Associate Dean Donald Bishop, of Cornell University’s School of Hotel
Administration, notes 51% of the schools student population is female. Brown
University has an undergraduate population that is 54% female. This follows a
nationwide pattern wherein females are exceeding males on campus. As cited
above, of the Ivy League schools, only Brown University and the Cornell
University School of Hotel Administration have a female majority. Dartmouth
College was the last of the Ivys to go co-ed in 1970. A decade and a half ago,
they had a policy which required the student population to be a 3:1 male/female
ratio. Men still outnumber females at seven of eight of the elite Ivy League
schools in America. In the final analysis, all segments of the hospitality
industry are prosperous. Prospective employees are entering a unique profession
that anticipates continued growth throughout this decade. It is the
responsibility of those who choose this industry to ensure its continued
prosperity.
Professor Steven E. Campbell has taught college for the past
15 years and has conducted seminars in hospitality and law-related topics at
conferences held throughout the United States and abroad. He currently
teaches hospitality and legal study courses at Delaware County Community College
in Media, PA.
|