Industry Move to One-Stop-Shopping Increases Competition in Financial Services
by Philana Patterson
While
the financial services industry is growing, the impact of technology, mergers
and acquisitions and legislation is rapidly changing the landscape. The Internet
and advances in telecommunications are making it easier for banks to deal
directly with consumers. Boundaries that once kept certain types of companies
from dabbling in others’ business have fallen down. Despite the upheaval,
revenue continues to grow, as do jobs – however, in many cases those jobs are
changing.
The
financial services industry is comprised of companies that help manage and grow
savings and investments for individuals, organizations or companies. These
functions are performed at commercial banks, securities firms, insurance
companies and at diversified financial companies that offer a variety of
products and services.
The
top three commercial banks, according to Fortune magazine are Bank of
America Corp. with more than $51 billion in revenue in 1999, followed by Chase
Manhattan Corp. with $33.7 billion and Bank One Corp. with nearly $26 billion.
In the securities industry, brokerages Merrill Lynch & Co., Morgan
Stanley Dean Witter and Goldman Sachs & Co. topped the list with $34.9
billion, $33.9 billion and $25.3 billion in revenue respectively in 1999.
In
the publicly traded property and casualty insurance arena, American
International Group, or AIG, tops the list with $40.7 billion in revenue. Next
is Allstate Insurance Co. with $27 billion in revenue followed by Berkshire
Hathaway Inc. with $24 billion in revenue, according to Fortune.
The top property-casualty mutual insurer, that is, companies
whose structures make policyholders stakeholders in the company, is State Farm
Insurance Cos. with $44.6 billion in sales, followed by Liberty Mutual Insurance
Group with $15.5 billion and Auto-Owners Insurance Co. with $2.4 billion.
In the life and health insurance sector, the largest publicly traded
company is Prudential Insurance Co. of America with more than $26 billion in
revenue while Metropolitan Life Insurance Co. comes in at a close second with
$25 billion in sales. American General Corp. rounds out the top three with more
than $10 billion in revenue. The
biggest mutual insurer in the life and health area is TIAA-CREF with $39.4
billion in revenue. New York Life Insurance Co. is second with $21.7 billion in
revenue and Northwestern Mutual Life Insurance Co. is third with $15.3 billion.
Excluding
General Electric Co., which in addition to financial operations owns media and
other operations, Citigroup Inc. leads diversified financial companies with $82
billion in revenue. Fannie Mae comes in second with $36.9 billion and Freddie
Mac third with $24.2 billion, according to Fortune’s survey.
The
economic boom in the late 1990s has made jobs in these types of companies
plentiful. Finance, insurance and real estate represented 19.1% of U.S. gross
domestic product (GDP), or more than $1.6 trillion in 1998, up from 18.8%, or
more than $1.5 trillion a year earlier, according to the Bureau of Economic
Analysis.
However,
the 1999 signing by President Clinton of the Financial Modernization Act, which
allows securities firms, banks and insurance companies to enter each other’s
markets, is changing the industry’s landscape. For example, now that insurance
companies can sell securities products, Allstate has begun selling mutual funds.
"That’s what people want," said Bill Howell, president of the
Insurance Education Foundation in Indianapolis. "They don’t want to go to one
place to get insurance and one place to get stocks. They want to go to one place
to get their insurance, stocks and do their banking." While financial services organizations are expected to get
bigger, mergers and acquisitions will reduce the number of them creating more
competition for jobs. The people working for these financial advising giants
will need to be the best at what they do – and be able to sell, market or work
with a variety of financial products. By
2008, the Bureau of Labor Statistics projects the percentage of jobs devoted to
the finance, insurance and real estate professions will fall slightly to 5.2% of
all U.S. jobs from 5.5% in 1998.
There
are financial rewards for people up to the challenge.
According to the National Association of Colleges and Employers' Summer
2000 Salary Survey, the middle-range of starting salaries in the insurance
industry was $30,420 to $37,000. Middle-range starting salaries in commercial
banking ranged from $27,000 to $39,000 and ranged from $40,000 to $45,000 in
investment banking. Additionally,
according to NACE, business administration graduates are enjoying big starting
salary jumps, with their average offering rising 6.5% from July 1999 to $35,991.
Accounting majors saw an increase of 7.1% to an average of $36,919 and marketing
graduates saw a 5.1% increase to $33,141. Mid-to-late career, financial services professionals can make
six-figure salaries. People at the top of the investment banking profession can
earn well into the millions annually.
The
consolidation industry watchers forecast a number of things could make entering
and surviving in the field challenging. The financial health of U.S. consumers
is a key factor. As Americans carry
the highest level of consumer debt in history, many don’t have a large amount
of money to dedicate to investing. Consumer spending, which had been at its
highest historical levels began to slow in the spring after the Federal Reserve
raised interest rates to cool-off an economy it believed was growing too
rapidly. As interest rates rise, consumers tend to have less money on hand and
need to allocate larger percentages of their income to service or pay down debt.
While economists don’t see it on the horizon now, if consumer spending
slows greatly, companies may eliminate jobs, which could lead to bigger
financial problems in the country. These conditions would make selling financial
services more challenging and could lead to downsizing in the financial services
and other industries.
While
there are traditional macroeconomic considerations, technology is changing the
economic cycle and has created a prolonged period of job and income growth in
the U.S. The financial industry is
increasingly using automation, the Internet and telephone customer service
centers to work with consumers. That will continue to expand the need for
workers interested in financial services careers who can work on the technology
side, said Edward C. Dolby (right), president, Bank of America – North and South
Carolina. Dolby, who heads up commercial, consumer, small business and affluent
banking (managing the assets of high net worth individuals), in the Carolinas,
expects banks to expand their use of sophisticated telephone systems, the
Internet and call centers to serve customers. To serve those needs, companies
will need computer programmers, Web designers as well as people who are
comfortable with telecommunications. When Bank of America said in July that it
would cut about 7% of its workforce or 10,000 employees - mostly in its middle
and senior management ranks and positions made obsolete by process improvements
– it said it would spend more money on e-commerce initiatives.
One
of the greatest opportunities in the industry is serving minority consumers.
Financial services firms are targeting minorities because they have already
deeply penetrated the white market. African Americans have the highest buying
power of any minority group, at $532 billion, up 73% since 1990, according to
the 1998 Multicultural American Dream Index study. The study was
performed by marketing firm Graham Gregory Bozell, research and consulting firm
Market Segment Research and management consulting firm DemoGraph Corp. to
measure economic and quality of life measurements of minorities. In 1997, there
were 259,000 African-American households with annual incomes of $100,000 or more
translating to 16% of all U.S. households at that level, according to the study.
When firms go after an African-American consumer, many are finding that an
African-American salesperson will get the sale more often than a salesperson of
another race."It’s
not altruistic," said Marsha Jones, who owns the New York-area branch of
ExecuSearch, a minority-owned executive search firm. "They’re doing it
because they need to. They’ve tapped out the other market."
Damon
R. Dyas, a certified financial planner with American Express Financial Advisors
in Southfield, Mich., has certainly found a lot of opportunity in the
African-American market. Dyas’s work involves helping people put together a
financial plan to meet their goals, whether it is saving for a house or for
their children’s college education. Then he helps them choose financial
instruments such as mutual funds, annuities or insurance policies to help them
achieve those objectives. He charges a fee for the financial plan and gets
commissions from the financial products he sells. Since starting with American
Express in 1993, the Michigan State University graduate’s client base has
evolved from being mostly white to 60% African American.
“The
door is open for African Americans in the financial services industry,’’
Dyas said. “The companies are realizing that our community is kind of an
untapped market. They realize that Black people have money, but that they may
not be directing it toward the right places.’’
Opportunities
to work in the insurance industry and to sell insurance to African Americans
have been plentiful for many years – but the industry, which often seems
stodgy or boring to outsiders, isn’t always an area that young people think to
explore. But the mere fact that African Americans buy a lot of insurance is a
great reason to enter the industry, said Thomas J. “T.J." Nicholson,
assistant field vice president for Allstate Insurance.
“African
Americans buy a lot of insurance and that’s a great reason to get into the
business,’’ Nicholson said. “We should get paid for it. There’s a direct
correlation between what you sell and what you make.’’
That’s
true for many sales-based professions in financial services. However, while many
companies are clamoring for minority talent, it’s not always easy for African
Americans to advance once they break into the industry, said Tony Chapelle (right),
publisher and editor of Securities Pro Newsletter, a New York-based
publication that tracks African Americans on Wall Street. He indicates part of
the problem is that often, African Americans don’t get worked into the culture
of the organizations. Sometimes they end up being somewhat isolated or
experience a clash in style with non-African-American counterparts or
supervisors."The
thing is Blacks have been able to get hired in the business, but the companies
have a hard time promoting and retaining them," Chapelle said. “They
don’t get pushed up the ladder like other folks.’’
There
are exceptions such as Thomas W. Jones, chairman and chief executive officer,
Global Asset Management and Private Banking Group and co-chairman of Salomon
Smith Barney Citi Asset Management Group; and Randall C. Hampton, president and
chief executive officer of ABN AMRO Asset Management. Both are African
Americans, who have climbed the ranks.
People
who want to position themselves for a financial services career may want to
consider pursuing an MBA, but that degree isn’t always necessary to get in the
door. Additionally, many MBA programs prefer for candidates to have several
years of work experience before they apply.
Undergraduate
students may want to consider majoring in disciplines such as accounting,
finance, economics or business administration and should be sure to have a solid
math background. However, there is room for people who get liberal arts degrees,
according to Dolby.
“Liberal
arts students will also be highly valued because they have more
flexibility,’’ Dolby said. “They have emotional skills that go a long way
when working with clients."
Also,
students and people early in their careers should seek out mentors, said Solomon
Hicks (right), Prudential Insurance’s top selling agent. He suggests finding people
who are on a path that appeals to you and tell them your goals.
“Tell
them ‘I want to be like you. I want to do what you’ve done,’" Hicks
said. “Let people know what your goals and dreams are."
People interested in the field
shouldn’t be afraid to take what, at first, may seem like a step back. Cid D.
Wilson (right), now a research associate in the Equity Research area of Citigroup
Inc.’s investment banking arm, Salomon Smith Barney, began his financial
services career in the mailroom of PaineWebber Inc.’s branch office near his
college. Aside from a
transportation and meal allowance, he was unpaid. While in the mailroom, he made
use of the pounds of extra investment research analysis that flowed into the
office.
"The cool thing was that I got all the research,’’ Wilson said.
"I
would take the research and read it and that helped me get up to speed about
what PaineWebber was thinking {about investing}.’’
Over the next four months, Wilson learned about evaluating stocks and
researching companies. He looked over stockbrokers’ shoulders to learn about
their jobs. He wiggled his way into meetings with portfolio managers and other
PaineWebber clients. Since he wasn’t being paid, there were few objections
when he asked to be a part of projects or meetings At the end of the four-month
stint, he was given a part-time position as a broker’s research assistant.
People
interested in financial services careers should read publications such as the Wall
Street Journal, Barron’s, other business news magazines and have a
general awareness of news and economic issues. Also, attending financial
planning seminars and joining professional organizations such as the National
Association of Securities Professionals, which works to expand the presence and
influence of minorities and women in the securities industry, is recommended.
Researching companies and learning about their values can help one decide
if that particular organization is a good fit.
“There
are certainly more opportunities for African Americans to advance," said
Sharon Taylor (right), corporate vice president and ethics officer, Individual Financial
Services at Prudential. “The key is preparation and performance. Given the
market dynamics and the pace of change, people need to be prepared for those
challenges," Taylor said.
Philana Patterson is a New York-based financial
journalist.
|