The Impact of Banking on Society is Awesome
by Phillip D. Woolfolk
Overview
The banking system with all its complexities, challenges and opportunities touches
virtually all aspects of our daily lives. Using a credit card to make a purchase, writing a
personal or business check, paying bills and moving funds online or accessing your funds
through an automatic teller machine are just a few examples of how you may participate
daily in the banking system. Even the local pawn shop provides banking-related services such as loans and check cashing in communities where those services are either
not readily available or where consumers perceive the pawnshop to be their best or only
banking alternative.
According to the Fannie Mae Foundation, pawnshops represent approximately 42 million transactions annually for a total of $3.3 billion in gross annual revenues.
In this article, we will address a number of topics including the types of services provided
by full service banks, demographic changes and potential opportunities, mergers and
acquisitions, regulatory issues and predatory lending challenges, financial literacy and
fringe banking services.
Changing Demographics and Potential Opportunities
The growth in minority populations across the country could have significant opportunities for college graduates over the next 10 to 20 years. This statement,
however, must be tempered by several assumptions without which corresponding opportunities for African-American college graduates may be minimal. First, we must
assume that the banking industry will accept the demographic trends as a bonafide
business opportunity to expand into relatively under-served communities including low
and moderate-income and minority communities. Second, we must assume that the banking industry believes that tapping into the minority community will yield bottom line
results in terms of shareholder value and profitability.
There is certainly significant data to suggest that profitability, business growth and
increased market penetration could be the outcome for the banks that aggressively
pursue the minority community as a business objective. One such example is Bank of
America and its strategic alliance with the National Association for the Advancement of
Colored People (NAACP). Bank of America is the third largest bank in the country
with assets of approximately $609.7 billion. This strategic alliance recognizes the viability of
expanding access to credit to low- and moderate- income communities, community-based
organizations and individuals for residential mortgage loans, small business loans and
community and economic development initiatives.
Fortunately many banks across the country are recognizing the business value of minority communities as emerging markets. Because, it is estimated in
the next 20 to 25 years, 38% of the population of the United States will consist of
minorities. The three major minority groups are expected to be African Americans,
Hispanic and Asian Americans.
Collectively, these three groups are expected to represent over one trillion dollars in
annual spending power. This suggests the potential for tremendous competition within
the banking industry for market share of minority dollars. These minority dollars offer the
industry a significant supply of potential low cost deposits. In the current interest rate
environment, mortgage rates, student loan rates and consumer loan rates in general
are relatively low. Banks need low cost deposits in the form of retail checking accounts,
savings accounts and certificates of deposit in order to improve profit margins.
If demographic and population trends follow expectations, the industry should yield
career opportunities at all levels. Opportunities could include entry-level positions such
as business support services, information technology, telecommunications, marketing,
advertising, sales, relationship managers, attorneys, accountants, compliance officers,
junior, middle and executive level managers, investment bankers, investment advisors,
insurance agents, consumer lenders, mortgage and commercial lenders to name a few.
Internships during your college years can serve as a key method of exploring whether a
career in the banking industry is right for you. I would encourage you to expand your
contacts and build relationships to include exposure to a wide variety of industries.
The business and economic environments of the new millennium are constantly changing, and you will serve yourself well by being prepared to adapt to those constant
changes.
Mergers, Acquisitions and Economic Downturn
As demographic and population trends offer potential opportunities, mergers, acquisitions, consolidations and economic downturn offer just the opposite.
With all of the mergers, acquisitions and consolidations prevalent in the banking industry,
you do not need to look far to see whether opportunities are shrinking or growing. Even
though population trends and changing demographics may change the landscape of opportunity in the future, a current view of the industry is those opportunities in the short-
term are shrinking. By way of example, Citigroup, which is the nation's largest bank with
assets of approximately $944.3 billion, less than $56 billion away from becoming
the country's first trillion-dollar bank, has filed with the Securities and Exchange
Commission (SEC) its intent to cut 3,500 more corporate and consumer jobs. This type
of trend certainly does not indicate the need for more bankers. As banks seek to reduce
expenses in order to pay for the mergers and acquisitions, and attempt to maintain
shareholder value and profitability, it remains to be seen how mergers and acquisitions,
when balanced against demographic changes and population trends, will ultimately
impact employment opportunities for African-American college graduates.
But, some banking executives remain optimistic. Barbara Lumpkin,
(left) senior vice president of The Northern Trust Company in Chicago, predicts the banking industry will continue to provide a wealth of opportunity for African-Americans across a broad spectrum of fields and disciplines. "The banking industry provides opportunities to work with and provide financial solutions for businesses, institutions and individuals. The African-American community is a powerful economic force in this country, and it needs and demands a complex array of sophisticated financial services and products. Solid, long-term careers exist and are being created on a daily basis in the banking industry to meet the specialized needs of focused communities," said Lumpkin. She continued, "In this light, input towards the creation and execution of bias-free and accessible financial services products can be more successfully developed by a representative end-user, and therefore, interesting and satisfying career opportunities exist in areas such as relationship management, finance, research, product development, sales and marketing, public relations, and advertising. And these opportunities exist at all levels -- from entry-level college graduates all the way up to the most seasoned senior executive posts."
The Industry Leaders
Collectively, the top 10 banks represent $3.7 trillion in assets and they span virtually
all regions of the country in distribution of retail branches, automated teller machines
(ATM's) and Internet banking. They provide valuable support to community-based organizations, provide discounted mortgages to low and moderate-income individuals,
and provide the financing to expand small businesses across the country.
|
Table 1 |
| Name |
City |
State |
Ticker |
Assets 1st
Qtr. 2001 |
| Citigroup, Inc. |
New York |
NY |
C |
$ 944,327,000 |
| J.P. Morgan Chase & Co. |
New York |
NY |
JPM |
$ 713,624,000 |
| Bank of America |
Charlotte |
NC |
BAC |
$ 609,755,000 |
| Wachovia * |
Charlotte |
NC |
WB |
$ 328,500,000 |
| Wells Fargo & Co. |
San Francisco |
CA |
WFC |
$ 279,670,000 |
| Bank One Corporation |
Chicago |
IL |
One |
$ 274,352,000 |
| Washington Mutual |
Seattle |
WA |
WM |
$ 219,925,000 |
| FleetBoston Financial |
Boston |
MA |
FBF |
$ 211,741,000 |
| U.S. Bancorp |
Minneapolis |
MN |
USB |
$ 160,274,000 |
| Sun Trust Banks, Inc. |
Atlanta |
GA |
ST |
$ 103,726,385 |
| Total Top 10 Assets |
|
|
|
$3,770,343,385 |
| * Recent change due to the Wachovia and First Union merger. |
| Data Source: Thompson Financial Web site, The Banking Channel at www.bankingchannel.com |
|
Table 2 |
|
Full-Service Banks-Retail Products and
Services |
| Basic Deposit Products |
Loan products |
Other Services |
| Savings |
Auto Loans |
Automated Teller Machine |
| Checking |
Student Loans |
On-line Banking |
| Money Market |
Personal Loans |
Trust Services |
| IRA |
Home Equity Loans |
Estate Planning |
| Annuities |
Unsecured Lines of CreditSafe |
Deposit Services |
| Mutual Funds |
Mortgage Loans |
Insurance Services |
| Certificates of Deposit |
Loans Secured By Savings |
|
| |
or Certificate of Deposit |
|
| |
Equipment Finance/Lease |
|
| |
Business Loans and Lines of Credit |
|
| |
Commercial Mortgages |
|
| |
Credit Cards |
|
Regulatory Environment
No article about the status of the banking industry would be complete without at least a
broad scope view of some of the regulatory issues confronting the industry. The impact
of some of the regulations could ultimately affect the cost of services to you as a
consumer. One such regulation is the Community Reinvestment Act or CRA, which was enacted specifically to hold the banking industry accountable to its regulatory
agency and to the communities it serves. The CRA encourages banks to meet the credit needs of
its entire community commonly referred to as its assessment area. Each year, the banks
provide an annual report on their activities. Bank performance is evaluated by federal
and/or state regulatory agencies using three tests including the lending, investment and
service tests.
In short, banks receive a rating of outstanding, satisfactory, needs improvement or
substantial non-compliance. This rating is very important to banks because it determines
whether regulatory agencies act favorably on applications by banks to open or close
branches, merge with or acquire other banks. The banks in the top 10 typically maintain
the appropriate ratings necessary to engage in expansion activities. A satisfactory CRA
rating ensures the ability to grow through mergers/acquisitions and maintain shareholder
value. Shareholder value helps to ensure adequate capital infusion to compete in an
industry where the ability to compete has become extremely difficult for banks with
assets of less than $10 billion.
The Community Reinvestment Act has served to increase access to credit to many low and moderate-income consumers and low and moderate-income
communities across the country, especially in the area of residential mortgage loans and
community and economic development initiatives. The CRA is under review by regulatory agencies who are soliciting public comments from the industry, community
groups and individuals regarding areas where there may be a need for reform. Consumer
groups have expressed recently that the CRA has improved access to credit and the next
frontier is to improve the terms of credit under which consumers must repay the credit
they receive. This brings us to the next challenge for the banking industry and lenders in
general, some of whom are not banks.
Predatory Lending
In the world of lending, we can best discuss predatory lending in the following context.
There are two types of consumers. First, there are consumers who qualify for the best
combination of interest rates, fees and loan terms known as prime borrowers. The
prime borrowers typically have good to excellent credit profiles. The credit profiles are
maintained by credit bureaus and credit scores are assigned based on the credit history
of the consumer. Second, there are consumers who have some blemishes in their credit
profiles and who in theory pose a higher repayment risk to the lender. These consumers would typically have lower credit scores and as a result pay higher interest
rates and fees. There is some debate about the concept of credit scores and how the scores are determined, and whether the factors used to determine the scores are fair
and equitable for all consumers regardless of such factors as education, income, and
residence. This pricing model based on actual credit risks and the potential of loan
default is known as risk-based pricing.
The loan provided to the consumer who poses the higher risk is known as a subprime
loan. Subprime loans at there best and when done responsibly provide a valuable service in the form of access to credit to consumers with less than perfect credit. The
economic basis for taking on the higher risk of default is the potential profitability tied to
interest rates and fees. There is very little debate about the need for and the value of
responsible subprime lending, and the legitimacy of responsible risk-based pricing.
Unfortunately, there are some lenders, most of whom are not banks, but some of whom
may be subsidiaries or affiliates of banks, who according to consumer advocates such as
the American Association of Retired Persons (AARP), have gone much too far in their
risk-based pricing analysis. Predatory lending, therefore, can be characterized as an
abusive lending practice that takes advantage of the actual or perceived risks associated
with a particular consumer or targeted group of consumers.
A predatory lender makes use of unfair and deceptive practices, which may include
outright fraud, unnecessary insurance, hidden fees, excessive interest rates and fees or
terms and conditions that systematically impede the borrower's ability to repay the loan
or adds excessive cost to the borrower beyond the associated risk of loan default.
There is a tremendous amount of pending and proposed legislative action around the
country on the topic of predatory lending. In an effort to protect consumers and
minimize the banking industry's cost of compliance, there will most likely be some form
of federal legislation to augment existing laws around unfair and deceptive practices and
other existing consumer protection laws in general.
Once you familiarize yourself with all sides of the issue, you may be of the opinion that
additional laws need to be enacted. You may be of the opinion that more resources need
to be allocated for the enforcement of existing laws. However, as this debate makes its
way through the local, state and federal legislative and legal process, one fact
remains; one of the most critical defenses against predatory lending is an educated consumer.
Fortunately, the banking industry participates in a major way in financial literacy and
with the assistance of community-based organizations, this knowledge and information
can help to curb the tide of predatory lending. The Consumer Bankers Association (CBA)
recently conducted a survey which indicated, "the banking industry has been diligent and
resourceful in its effort to advance financial literacy… Industry commitment is
evident in the readiness demonstrated to create partnerships, develop and deliver
curricula [and] help fund organizations providing financial education."
Participants in the survey included 48 banks representing more than half of the industry's
assets, and they indicated they participate in financial literacy efforts in some
way. You may visit CBA online at www.cbanet.org for the complete report.
One of the components of predatory lending has been the financing of single premium
life insurance. Citigroup, for example, which recently acquired a sub-prime lender,
announced that they would no longer finance the single premium credit life insurance in their mortgages. Consumers may ultimately be able to purchase this type of
insurance on a pay-as-you-go basis. The heightened awareness of predatory lending will
most likely apply market pressures and create greater competition for prime and subprime
loans. There is clearly significant data to warrant greater access to banking services in
low and moderate-income communities, as these communities, along with minority and
elderly individuals, tend to be the most vulnerable to predatory lenders.
| Table
3 |
|
Fringe Banking Services |
| Service |
Annual Transaction Volume |
Annual Gross Revenues ($) |
| Check Cashing |
180 million |
60 billion |
| Payday Loans |
55-69 million |
10-13.8 billion |
| Pawn Shops |
42 million |
3.3 billion |
| Rent-to-Own |
3 million |
4.7 billion |
| Total |
280 million |
78 billion |
| Data Source: Fannie Mae Foundation |
In addition, table 3 indicates additional growth markets exist for the banking industry in
general, and innovative banks in particular. The banking industry, with its various
challenges, continues to perform financial services every community needs to become
full participants in the American free enterprise system. As you decide on your future
professional opportunities, be sure to educate yourself in the intricacies of free enterprise,
so you and your community may benefit from all free enterprise has to offer. Good luck
and enjoy your journey!

Phillip D. Woolfolk is the vice president and Fair Lending manager of the Sovereign Bank in the Philadelphia, PA area.
|