Retailing-Growth and Opportunities Abound
by George R. Auzenne
As a matter of curiosity, I often ask students on campus the
question: "What is retailing?" Not surprisingly, the answers are vague
and are characterized by the naming of retail stores. When asked what jobs exist
in retailing, the answers are somewhat more forthcoming: "Sales," some
will say. Others, usually those who've worked in the retail sector before will
answer: "Sales Associate." Beyond that, the respondents cannot think
of other job titles, with the possible exception of "buyer." These
uninformed answers give me the opportunity to explain the opportunities which
exist in retailing and the nature of retailing. I will elaborate here also.
Let us first define retailing as the exchange of money for goods and
services. There is always someone in the market looking for something to buy,
whether that something is a service or a tangible good, and there is always
someone else who has, and is willing, to sell what the buyer is looking for.
Retailing involves, then, much more than selling by such well-known stores as
Wal-Mart, Sears, Target, JCPenney, etc. It involves every licensed transaction
that you can imagine, from your local barbershop to your local record store.
Retailing is the heartbeat of the economy, because without a smooth-functioning,
licensed retail sector, our economy would, in fact, collapse. It is no wonder
then that retailing is a multi-trillion dollar business and employs millions of
people. It is also because retailing is so multi-faceted that it renders the
subject difficult to talk about with any degree of clarity. But I will try to
make some sense of this economic sector which surrounds us all and with which we
interact everyday.
Industry Structure
It order to discuss retailing in an orderly fashion, let us begin with the
fact that retailers are separated into categories. Categories can be
thought of as a group of related products which are sold by retailers which
compete against each other. Let us take furniture as an example. There are many
stores selling furniture-some are purely local, many are national chains. The
goods sold by furniture stores are pretty much the same, however, varying only
in quality and price. Furniture as a category, then, involves a number of
competitors (firms), each trying to outsell the other. I am going to provide
over several examples of retail categories below, and simultaneously, identify
some of the leading firms in that category. As you read the list of these
categories, realize that these are but a few of the many categories which exist,
and each category needs people to work. If you are a college graduate, you are
in great demand for the opportunities that exist beyond the entry-level job. It
is wise to also remember that different writers define retail categories
differently depending on what their purposes might be.
Department Stores
One of the most familiar of all retail categories is the department store.
You undoubtedly have several in your hometown. When we speak of department
stores, we think of such names as Sears, JCPenney, and depending upon where you
live, such names as Kohls, Dillard’s, Burdines, Macy’s, Bloomingdale’s,
Rich’s, Filene’s, Foley’s, Parisian, Saks, or Neiman Marcus. It is not
possible to talk about a leader when discussing department stores because each
is aimed at a particular market, usually based on the income level of the
intended customers. Sears has traditionally marketed itself as a
"family" store, while Saks has sought to attract affluent customers
who can afford the high-price items it carries. It might be said, however, that
Sears is considered the number two retailer (behind Wal-Mart) both in the
country and in the world.
Discount Stores
The discount store is relatively a newcomer, as far as being identified as a
separate category. Mention discount stores and we immediately think of the big
three: Wal-Mart, Kmart, and Target. Wal-Mart is the undisputed leader in
this category and holds the distinction of being the largest retailer in the
world. Kmart, among the oldest in the discount store category, has consistently
done well and continues to enjoy a position near the top in this category.
Target, a Division of Dayton-Hudson Stores, has done well since its inception
and has become the top moneymaker for its parent company.
Supermarkets
Supermarkets are such a pervasive part of our lives that we seldom think of
them as "retailers." But that is just what they are. They retail food
to customers in every community and represent an increasingly sophisticated
business with very exciting opportunities. Think of supermarkets and we think,
again depending on where you live, of such familiar names as Albertson’s, Food
Lion, HEB, Kroger, Publix, Safeway, or Winn-Dixie. Among the leaders in this
category are such venerable names as Kroger, Safeway, Albertson’s, and Winn-Dixie.
Many supermarket chains are regionalized. That is they operate primarily in only
one part of the country. Examples of this are HEB (Texas) and Publix (Florida).
Nationally, the largest supermarkets are Kroger, Albertson’s and Safeway. The
concept of "largest" can be misleading, however, because many large
and profitable supermarkets dominate their local or regional markets to the
extent that the industry leaders may not be present in that market at all.
Consumer Electronics
Consumer electronics have become an important retail category as increasingly
sophisticated microprocessors have made more and more electronic consumer goods
available. Electronic goods as a retail category are associated primarily with
personal or home-based entertainment goods. Such items as television sets, CD
players, VCRs, and now, DVD players, consume an increasing part of personal and
household expenditures. If computers for the home--whether desktops or laptops
--are added to the list of consumer electronics, we have a category which has
continued to increase in sales since its inception. In this category, we have
such names as Circuit City, Best Buy, and Tandy. There is great diffusion in
this category because the goods they sell tend to be sold by a variety of other
retailers also. For example, while Circuit City sells televisions and computers,
so do Wal-Mart and Sears.
Pharmaceutical Retailers
Pharmaceutical retailers, better known as drug stores, represent a growing
category in the retail sector as the population of the United States continue to
get older and as medical science produces more and more pharmaceuticals for
every ailment or condition. Once this category consisted of family-owned
businesses, but it is now almost an entirely chain-based enterprise. Among the
premier names in this category are Walgreen’s, CVS and Rite-Aid. This short
list does not consider that many since most pharmaceuticals are sold in other
venues such as discount stores and supermarkets.
Specialty Apparels
This is a somewhat mixed-bag category because it includes retail companies of
many different types and which are aimed at a variety of markets. This category
contains however, some of the most successful retailers in the country. Among
the instantly recognizable names in this group are: The Gap, which includes Old
Navy and Banana Republic; The Limited; Intimate Brands; Ann Taylor; Men’s
Warehouse; Ross; and TJ Maxx. These primarily mall-based stores are practically
household names and continue to perform excellently in most cases, year after
year.
The different categories briefly discussed before provide a clue as to why it
is difficult to categorize retailers meaningfully by size. National sales and
earnings figures provide an indication, however. Below, I list some of the
leaders in revenues and earnings in retailing. The figures for the most part are
taken from Stores magazine, a publication of the National Retail
Federation. The figures given are for 1998, the last year for which complete
data are available. Looking at 1999 quarterly reports, the rankings have not
changed significantly. It should be kept in mind that the figures given do not
always include the recent entry of many traditional retailers in the use of the
Internet as a sales channel. To the extent that such figures are reliably
available, I have provided them separately. The top ten retailers for 1998
listed by Stores magazine in ranking order were:
Sales Earnings
1. Wal-Mart $137,634,000,000 $ 4, 430,000,000
2. Sears $41,322,000,000 $ 1, 088,000,000
3. Kmart $33,674,000,000 $ 518,000,000
4. Dayton Hudson $30,951,000,000 $ 935,000,000
5. JC Penney $30,678,000,000 $ 594,000,000
6. Home Depot $30,219,000,000 $ 1,614,000,000
7. Kroger $28,203,000,000 $ 411,657,000
8. Safeway $24,484,200,000 $ 806,700,000
9. Costco $24,269,877,000 $ 459,842,000
10. American Stores $19,866,725,000 $ 233,744,000
It should be noted that American Stores, the tenth ranked retailer, has been
acquired by Albertson’s Supermarket chain.
E-commerce is such a new phenomenon, that a good metric by which performance
can be assessed, has not been completely developed. The September, 1999 issue of
Stores magazine provides an indication of the trends in the industry. It
should be noted however, that the e-commerce retail sector is very volatile and
that the figures provided should be read with caution. The following retail
figures are estimates through July, 1999 as measured by sales to customers on
the Internet only. That is the figures given do not reflect sales which
retailers may have made using catalogs or through bricks and mortar stores. The
top five sites are listed:
Rank Web site Product/Service Estimated Internet Sales
1 eBay.com Auction venue $ 1.1 to 1.3 billion
2 Amazon.com Books/Media $ 1.0 to 1.1 billion
3 Dell.com Computers $ 500-600 million
4 Buy.com Computers/Media $ 350-400 million
5 OnSale.com Computers/software $ 300-350 million
The diverse retail categories previously cited and some of the industry
leaders provide a glimpse of the variety of retailers, available work settings,
and profitability one might enjoy in retailing. The question still remains,
however, what kinds of jobs might one expect to find and are these good jobs?
Job Structure Within Retailing
That many people are employed by the retailing sector is a given. In fact,
most individuals obtain their first jobs in some retail outlet. We are concerned
here with the career jobs in retailing and those for which retailers are
increasingly looking for college graduates to fill. These are the jobs, which
normally cannot be performed by just "anyone," and require either a
college degree or extensive training or experience. Four major job-types in
retailing may be identified. They are management; which includes managing
departments and functions within a store or managing the entire store;
merchandising, which is a broad category that more often than not, includes
buying or purchasing; distribution and logistics, which involves the movement of
merchandise from distribution centers and manufacturing facilities to the retail
outlets; and support functions within the company which include data processing,
accounting, finance, marketing, advertising, human resources management, and
other related functions needed to operate a profitable business. Increasingly
now, we must begin to add another category of job types, that of the manager of
online retailing. Selling goods on the Internet is perhaps the fastest growing
segment of the retail market. The knowledge of how to best sell on the Internet
goes beyond the mere knowledge of knowing how to manipulate software or program
a computer.
For the college graduate, training programs of varying duration are required.
Previous experience in retailing, especially internship experience, is an
important consideration when being considered for a permanent job in any one of
the job types. Each of the job types within retailing has its own
"ladder," meaning there are ranks within the type in which the
individual can progress to the top of that job type. Lateral moves are also
possible. A person may begin his/her career in buying, but decide later that
he/she prefers human resources. Once a basic understanding of the firm has been
obtained, and some work experience in the firm accumulated, the move to a
different job type is not difficult.
African Americans and Retailing
For sound business reasons, African Americans are in great demand in
retailing. But often overlooked is the fact that, beyond
"business-sociological" reasons, all firms need talent, and retail
talent is not confined to skin color. In short, if you have ambition and are
willing to work, there is a place for you in retailing. In view of this, a
number of African Americans from a variety of firms have been interviewed to
share their observations and concerns.
One of the first impressions received by this writer in conducting interviews
with African Americans in retailing is that all had been in retailing a number
of years and each had been with his/her present company a long time. The amount
of time a person stays with a firm is usually one indicator of the degree of
satisfaction with the company. And secondly, the amount of time spent in
retailing is also a proxy for satisfaction with the kind of work being done.
Several people featured in this article have been employed in retailing from six
to over 20 years. Each occupies a position of status, authority, and influence.
Each has professed a high degree of satisfaction with what he/she does and
personal observations confirm this. When asked what is it about retailing that
each found personally rewarding, the answers varied, but a careful reading
suggests that retailing offers sufficient autonomy to permit individuals to be
as ambitious as desired. Also mentioned frequently was that the variety of tasks
involved is broad and provides an exciting environment in which to work. Wayne
Terry, a senior corporate recruiter with HEB Grocery Company in San Antonio, TX,
has worked for the company for 14 years and he emphasized the psychological
rewards. " I started with the company right out of college and I have not
regretted my decision once. I have had a variety of jobs with the company and
the opportunity to grow with each one. I am in a position, which is not only
personally fulfilling, but I know I can influence others. I really like what I
do."
Addison Holmes, director of Internal Consulting and Auditing Services for The
GAP, Inc., in San Francisco, CA, talked about the retail environment as a place
to work. " Retailing is an environment which requires creativity. The
amount of creativity you are permitted depends upon the company and the job you
are doing, but retailers succeed to the extent that they have imaginative,
creative people generating ideas and new and better ways to sell products. If
you thrive in the kind of atmosphere where your ideas can matter, then retailing
is the right environment for you. If you are a creative person, then retailing
is the place for you."
Vanessa Brown, a cosmetics buyer with Dillard’s in St. Petersburg, FL,
addressed the issue of pay. "Initial pay is comparable to, and often better
than most entry-level positions in the service sector. The exciting thing about
retailing is that you can realize pay growth very quickly and within a few years
find that you are making salaries surpassing $50,000. Depending upon the
company, store managers with a few years of experience usually make in excess of
$100,000 per year. This is the part of retailing that students often don’t
realize."
Sharon Robinson, a store manager with Target Stores in Sarasota, FL, states
that retailing is a great choice for African Americans at this time. She has
been in retail management for 17 years and has worked for Marshall’s and
Sears, prior to assuming her present responsibilities with Target. "Most
retailers are in great need for store managers because competition is becoming
much keener than it used to be and most successful retailers are expanding. As
our customer base becomes more diverse, we need diversity in people we have
managing our stores." When asked what is it that she likes about her job,
she was quick to answer: "Being a leader and having the chance to develop
other people. That is one of the most rewarding things I do. My job requires
that I spend a lot of time following up to see that the standards set are
upheld. That is not only a teaching opportunity, but it is the time when you
must show leadership. I love it!"
Conclusion
The opportunities available in retailing are often overlooked because of
misconceptions about professional growth opportunities in the business. Yet the
world’s economy is based on the selling of goods and services, which is what
retailing is all about. The demand for college-trained retail managers continues
to be great and the tremendous growth of retailing on the Internet has only
increased the need for skilled, technologically smart retailers. Professional
retailing requires the most skilled people available and in the final analysis
is often very rewarding.
George R. Auzenne is the director of the Retail Management
Program at Florida A&M University in Tallahassee, FL.
|